Heat pump vs gas boiler
6 min read below · SolarFast comparisons
Heat pump or gas boiler: the difference in efficiency, cost and comfort, and when a boiler is (still) the logical choice. An honest per-home trade-off.
A heat pump turns one kilowatt-hour of power into three to five kilowatt-hours of heat; a gas boiler never extracts more heat than the gas contains. That is why the heat pump wins on consumption and CO2. The boiler remains logical when your home is not ready yet: poorly insulated, or the boiler was just replaced. The hybrid route sits in between.
Get started
Heat pump
View and request a quoteShare this article
The gas boiler has been the standard for decades; the heat pump is its successor on electricity. Below we compare the two on efficiency, cost, comfort and the question that matters most: is your home ready? What insulation has to do with it is covered in our guide on insulation and heat pumps.
The options side by side
Heat pump
Pros
- Three to five kilowatt-hours of heat per kilowatt-hour of power
- Considerably lower CO2 emissions than a gas boiler
- Less or no gas use and eventually no gas standing charge
- Dutch ISDE subsidy available
Cons
- Higher upfront investment
- Needs suitable insulation and low-temperature heat delivery
- The outdoor unit needs a spot
Gas boiler
Pros
- Low purchase price and quick to replace
- Works in any house, even poorly insulated
- Compact, no outdoor unit
Cons
- Efficiency can never exceed the energy content of the gas
- Fully dependent on the gas price
- No subsidy and no route to gas-free
The efficiency difference in plain language
A modern condensing boiler is a fine machine, but there is one thing it cannot do: deliver more heat than the energy contained in the gas. A heat pump can, because it does not make heat but moves it: it extracts warmth from the outdoor air and pumps it into your home. From one kilowatt-hour of power it makes three to five kilowatt-hours of heat, according to Milieu Centraal (Dutch). How that efficiency is expressed is covered under COP and SCOP.
Add the climate gain: compared with a condensing boiler, CO2 emissions for heating and hot water drop by a good 30 to 70 percent, depending on use and how green the power is, per the same source. What it means for your power consumption is calculated via what a heat pump consumes.
Cost: purchase versus consumption
The boiler wins on the purchase receipt, the heat pump on the annual bill. How quickly that flips depends on your heat demand, insulation and energy prices; that is why we calculate it per home instead of scattering averages. For the heat pump there is also the ISDE subsidy via RVO (Dutch); a new gas boiler gets no subsidy.
| Heat pump | Gas boiler | |
|---|---|---|
| Energy source | Power (plus outdoor air or ground) | Natural gas |
| Efficiency | 3 to 5 kWh of heat per kWh of power | Never more heat than the gas contains |
| Purchase | Higher investment | Lower investment |
| Subsidy | ISDE possible | None |
| Requirements on the home | Insulation and low-temperature delivery | None |
| Cooling in summer | Often possible | No |
Efficiency and CO2 gain per Milieu Centraal; subsidy conditions via RVO (ISDE). We deliberately leave amounts out; they are current in your quote.
When is the gas boiler (still) the logical choice?
Honest answer: sometimes it is. If your home is poorly insulated and there is no budget to insulate first, a fully electric heat pump becomes expensive to run; hot radiators push the efficiency down. If your boiler was just replaced, scrapping it is rarely rational. And in some situations, such as a listed building that can hardly be insulated, gas remains practical for now.
What does work in those cases: the hybrid route. The heat pump does the daily work, the existing boiler covers the coldest days and the hot water. You immediately save most of your heating gas without your house having to be perfect yet. The full trade-off is in hybrid vs all-electric.
Comfort and daily use
A heat pump heats differently from a boiler: calmer and more constant, with a lower water temperature. If you are used to cranking the thermostat five degrees in the evening, it takes adjusting; a heat pump prefers to hold an even temperature all day. Many people find that more comfortable, but it is a different way of heating.
Two more practical differences: a heat pump with an outdoor unit makes noise (rules apply, and a good setup prevents hassle), and many all-electric heat pumps can also cool in summer. No gas boiler has an answer to that.
How SolarFast advises on this
During the survey we look at your insulation, heat delivery, gas consumption and fuse box. From that follows honest advice: switch fully now, take the hybrid step first, or insulate first and leave the boiler for now. Put your situation to us or see the heat pump page.
Verdict
If your home is reasonably to well insulated, the heat pump wins the comparison: far higher efficiency, considerably less CO2 and a subsidy on top. If your house is not ready or the boiler is brand new, the hybrid route or insulating first is the sober choice. A new gas boiler without a plan behind it is the one option we rarely advise: it buys you fifteen years of gas dependency.
Related articles
Heat pump insulation: why and what you need
Without good insulation a heat pump works harder and costs more to run. How to test at 50 degrees and choose between hybrid or all-electric.
How much power does a heat pump use?
A heat pump's power use depends on your heat demand and the SCOP. How to run the numbers yourself, and what pushes consumption up or down in practice.
What do COP and SCOP mean?
COP and SCOP tell you how much heat a heat pump delivers per kWh of power. The difference between the two figures and how to read them in a quote.
Underfloor heating and heat pumps: ideal match?
Why underfloor heating and a heat pump work so well together, when radiators are enough and what fitting it in an existing floor involves.
Hybrid vs all-electric heat pump
Hybrid or all-electric heat pump: how insulation drives the choice, what you save on gas, and how the heating test shows if your home is ready.
Air-to-air vs air-to-water heat pump
Air-to-air (AC unit) or air-to-water heat pump? The differences in hot water, cooling and subsidy, and when each system fits. Honest advice from practice.
Frequently asked questions
Is a heat pump more efficient than a gas boiler?
Yes, by a wide margin: a heat pump turns one kilowatt-hour of power into three to five kilowatt-hours of heat, while a boiler never delivers more heat than the energy in the gas. Whether it also wins in euros depends on your insulation and energy prices; we calculate that per home.
Can a heat pump replace any gas boiler?
Technically almost always, but it is only sensible once your home fits: enough insulation and a heat delivery system that handles lower water temperatures. If that is not there yet, hybrid or insulating first is the better route.
When is a gas boiler still the best choice?
With a poorly insulated home and no budget to insulate first, with a boiler that was just replaced, or with a home that can hardly be insulated. In many of those cases a hybrid heat pump is still a sensible interim step.
Do I get a subsidy if I switch?
The Dutch ISDE subsidy is available for heat pumps; current conditions and amounts are published by RVO. There is no subsidy for a new gas boiler.
What happens to my hot water?
With an all-electric heat pump the hot water comes from a storage tank at the unit. In a hybrid setup the gas boiler keeps providing the hot water. We include that difference in the advice.
Does a heat pump heat in freezing weather?
Yes. Efficiency is lower on cold days than on mild ones; in a hybrid setup the boiler steps in. For all-electric we size the capacity so the house stays warm through a cold spell.
Can I also cool with a heat pump?
Many all-electric heat pumps can cool in summer through the heat delivery system, such as the floor. It is mild cooling, not air conditioning, but it makes a noticeable difference on hot days. A gas boiler has no such function.
Need help choosing?
We help you make the right choice for your home and energy use.